0

Home Grown: Canary

Barn-find of the year: Canary shows that fresh ears, not gear, is what it takes to record a stunning debut album, with beat boxing no less.

By

18 April 2012

It could have gone so wrong. Sending a few beat boxing musicians – who are admitted novices at tracking – out to a barn to record a debut album, on GarageBand, with a PreSonus Firestudio. It’s galling in a way; that these precocious upstarts have side-skipped any kind of formal introduction to the art of recording, used what was ‘lying around’, and shock horror, relied on their ears to educate themselves. And they’ve actually done it. Melbourne band Canary has managed to make a debut album that sounds both lush and huge, intimate and layered without acquiring a major-label-sized recording bill.

Canary’s album Dear Universe is a truly impressive piece of work featuring great songwriting, creative arrangements, a fascinating range of styles and instrumentation (everything from beat-boxing to horns, violins and aggressive rock guitars), and to top it off the record has great sonics courtesy of time taken with mic and room placements. Not to mention the sage advice and well structured mixes courtesy of experienced producer/mixer Isaac ‘Zac’ Barter.

FRESH EARS

To get the skinny on how the whole thing went down I caught up with singer/multi-instrumentalist Matt Keneally.

Greg Walker: Firstly congratulations on the record – it’s a rich and complex piece of work. Can you talk a little about how you approached the recording process? Did you have a clear vision for it or did it slowly evolve?

Matt Keneally: We didn’t really know what we were doing initially. We didn’t have an overall sound in mind but wanted to include a diverse array of different sounds and it evolved as we went along. We knew it was going to be colourful. And we had a certain sense of freedom knowing that we weren’t aiming for a specific sound, genre or style. It was more a case of, ‘let’s have fun recording these songs in whatever way we want to or feel is best for each and then at the end, see what we have.’ I suppose one clear direction was that, being long-time fans of Elliott Smith, we wanted to double track a lot of the vocals and acoustic guitars. It’s a sound we’ve always loved, and it worked pretty well with the vocals and the style of at least a few of the songs. That was the default, and then sometimes we pared it back to just one vocal where it suited.

GW: Whereabouts did you do the recording? 

MK: We did all the tracking in a barn in Nagambie, various rooms in the house I was living in at the time, most of the drums in Zac’s house, the violin in Adam’s living room and beat-boxing in Nagambie and Ed’s bedroom. It really just came down to what was the most convenient. Because we tracked it in so many different rooms I was a little concerned about consistency in the album’s sounds. Zac assured me that there was enough similarity, continuity, etc., in the content and the writing itself for it to work as an album. To save on costs the initial plan was that Adam and myself would borrow a bunch of mics off Zac and try to track it all ourselves. Zac would then mix it all afterwards. He’s a Mac user so we tracked it all into GarageBand via a PreSonus Firestudio interface before giving it to Zac to mix. He was using Logic Pro and so we were able to drop in the GarageBand files and keep the initial rough mixing settings we’d put on while tracking it all. 

Zac Barter in his studio: “We did things like layering six takes of cymbals in unison to surprisingly good effect. Everything was mixed in the box and this allowed the flexibility and workflow we needed.”

SLOW & STEADY

GW: Was it a long process to make the record?

MK: It took us about a year overall. The bulk of the recording was done on and off within probably four or five months, whereas the mixing was done relatively casually and took most of the year. It took us a lot longer than professionals to initially track it all because Adam and I were constantly second-guessing everything. “Is that the right amount of gain level? Are the headphones too loud? Is it too roomy a sound? Can you hear the rain outside? There’s a slight hum, do you reckon it’ll matter?” A lot of it was resolved by a quick phone call to Zac. I’d spoken to him in detail beforehand about how we should do it and whether it was a bad idea for us to go off and try tracking it ourselves. He instilled a lot of confidence in Adam and myself to trust our ears and so, not knowing a lot about what the ‘right’ way of recording stuff was, we did our best to trust our ears out of necessity. From the start, I knew Zac and myself were on the same page with general sounds we were after in the album. We wanted it to be at times raw, stripped back and at other times, fairly produced and complex. So I had a lot of trust in him and his advice. As we were recording I’d check in with Zac to see if the sounds we were getting were usable. He was usually very re-assuring and quite amazing as an overseer to work with. This relationship allowed us enough freedom to muck around and experiment while still making sure we were getting good sounds.

GW: What were some of the hurdles you had to overcome soundwise?

MK: There were some results that were less than ideal. For instance we had an Audio-Technica 3035 above and behind the violin as well as a line out from the violinist’s amp on Very Impressive. But the acoustic sound ended up being way too roomy so we ended up almost exclusively using the line out takes. The guitars at the end of Little Christ were recorded at least three times – each time they were too ‘roomy’ (I was living in a house at the time that was all wooden floors and high ceilings). I took them to Zac twice and both times he suggested doing them again so he had something better to work with. On the third time, I got lucky. I ended up basically burying the mic and amp in pillows and blankets and a mattress.

GW: What gear were the main and backing vocals recorded with?

MK: They were all done with an AT 3035 going into a PreSonus Firestudio interface and then into GarageBand. Zac also used some ribbon mics for the backing vocals on Son and Father.

GW: The acoustic guitars sound great on this record. What were the instruments and the recording chain for that?

MK: There were a few different approaches to the acoustic guitar sounds. Usually I had the mic a few centimetres off the point where the neck and body of the guitar meet (I assume that’s fairly standard) using my AT 3035. All the guitar tracks were recorded mono. It’s a nice sounding guitar to begin with (Yamaha Compass Series CPX) and I usually had a mattress or something behind the mic to play into and most were just recorded in various bedrooms or lounge rooms. For tracks 12 and 13 we actually used an Elliott Smith technique. I’d asked Zac at some point early on in frustration, “How does Elliott get that sound?” So Zac looked it up. It turns out that often he had the mic placed somewhere about halfway between the guitar and his mouth (sitting position) and recorded playing and singing at the same time, and then double tracked it. So I liked the idea and thrill of having that ‘live’ pressure and we gave it a try. It was sounding vibey instantly and we didn’t have to do a lot mixing-wise to get it working. Those takes were actually recorded in a really nice bedroom in the barn. It had a few different angles in the ceiling and was a combination texture-wise of straw/mudbrick, metal, concrete and a rug.

COMBINING THREE SONGS TO SAVE LITTLE CHRIST

Isaac Barter: “It was a really difficult mix because it was originally three separately recorded songs that we then wanted to fit together smoothly. It also had huge dynamic range with parts that could easily be overwhelmed by other instruments. I split Ed’s beat boxing into three separately treated tracks essentially for depth, body, and attack. They then went through a few busses for more processing. After extensive exploration with a range of distortion, compression, frequency splits, etc., I stumbled across a sound that I liked. Bass tracks ended up going through some nasty metal distortion and I added some synth bass for Prelude using Olga. I liked Matt’s pick tone better than mine for the end bass riff so got him to play it.

“We re-recorded some of the guitar tracks using a Japanese reissue Telecaster through a Vox AC30 and Adam added some great Juno synth parts. Ed’s trumpet parts were twisted with lots of Crystallizer and bizarre free plugins Crazy Ivan and Bouncy. The end vocals were split and heavily filtered and delayed to get the right sense of space. I tried quite a few distortions on these vocals before settling on the Logic amp sim. Great distortion can come from the strangest of places! Xani’s violins had a long wall of thick distorted Echoboy delay and Matt kept getting me to turn them up along with the shouting until they completely overwhelmed the band. This became especially aggressive in the mastered version as the song starts to distort and squash under the limiter. I still can’t make up my mind if I like it that smashed, but there is definitely something exciting about it.”

OUT OF THE BOX

GW: The use of beat boxing on the record is really effective, is that something you’ve always done in the band?

MK: Beat boxing was something we definitely had been doing from the beginning. Being heavily into artist’s like Bjork and Radiohead at the time of the band’s inception, I loved the electronic and unorthodox sounds they produced. To me they weren’t at all distracting but refreshing and very interesting. So, not being computer savvy enough to mess around with beat programming and loops, I decided to use the next best thing – beat boxing. Looking back, I’m not entirely sure why, but I wanted to steer away from a typical ‘band’ sound; acoustic drums, bass, acoustic guitar, electric guitars, that sort of thing. So we went with electric violin (Xani Kolac), trumpet, synth and beat boxing. It certainly was a bit of a headache at times for Zac and I. I guess we just wanted to force ourselves to be as creative as we could and try and create something unique. Using odd instruments does often help with this. We actually spent the majority of the first trip up to Nagambie tracking the beat boxing tracks. I can’t express how disheartening it was initially. We discovered that beat boxing, at least the way we were doing it, doesn’t sound great immediately the way drums or most other things do. A fair bit of work has to be done to make them listenable and suitable to record other stuff over. And then they require a fair bit of tweaking as different elements gets added to the mix. There was a point early on in mixing the beat boxing where I just couldn’t keep up with the different compressors, EQs and limiters.

GW: Little Christ seems to be a song that exemplifies the album. Could you take us into a bit more detail and describe the conception, recording and production of that song?

MK: The basic concept for the song definitely evolved, but I knew from the start that I wanted it to be ballsey, dramatic, colourful, and intense. I was really happy when Zac showed me a fairly dark, pared back mix of it which brought more attention to the vocals and guitar parts giving it all a slightly sinister and much more snappy feel. Like a lot of the initial dumpings of tracks I gave to Zac, there was just too much. I believe after messing around a bit in the mastering, he applied a fairly hefty limiter on the loud build up section in the middle. We tried just letting it go without limiting it here at all but we actually really liked the crunch it was getting and that feeling of everything getting squashed. The beat boxing was laid down first in Ed’s bedroom. I believe he used an Audix i5 on this one. Everything else was done using an EV RE20. I think I just got him to lay out the rough form before it was really finished and then we may have looped a section in the end. Then Zac recorded a bass track, and I recorded the guitars and most of the vocals to the first half in a basement of a friend’s house. All brick walls and low ceilings but I liked the darkness and brittleness that the guitars and vocals naturally had there. Violins for this song were done in Adam’s living room. It wasn’t a great room or great acoustic sound in the end but Zac managed to make it work. After it was all roughly mixed I got an old friend to ‘preach’ for a bunch of takes and then speak in tongues. I don’t know if I’ll ever be able to describe how weird that was to have him really trying to get into the role in front of me in a bedroom, both of us with headphones on. It was awesome. I think Zac put all the spoken stuff through some sort of reverb or ‘blown speaker’ emulating EQ to try and make it sound like a preacher getting into it in a small church.

GW: What did the mixing process entail?

MK: Overall the mixing on this song was a fair chore – the beat boxing mainly. It went through a lot of different EQs before settling on a fairly dark and stripped back mix in general. This was definitely a song where we pared back the parts to find the least amount that we could work with. Everything shifted around a lot until we finally settled on a balance between the bass and guitars and vocals that worked. Both Zac and I are cursed with a certain pickiness, and the parts and instruments were often tricky to ‘fit’ together.

I enjoy working with and mixing bands that record themselves although it is high risk and comes with problems. It’s vital to find the right space and to have a band with great ears and patience.

THE SAGE ADVISOR

The man consistently on the other end of Keneally’s phone, Zac Barter, talks about the mixing process and what it was like to handle the raw material coming in from the barn.

Zac Barter: “Canary was performing the songs on the album well before recording began, so they usually had a clear starting arrangement but they also wanted to experiment heavily. The original plan was for a more conventional studio album but Matt’s rough old demos with a Behringer mixer into a soundcard convinced me that he performed better when he recorded himself. The band started tracking themselves in Nagambie with a few mics and a Firestudio running into GarageBand. The room was well suited to recording with angled walls and played a big part in the sound of the album. For the acoustic tracks Matt found a spot that he liked under the staircase and usually played a Yamaha Compass. I can’t stand the feel of that guitar but love how it records when Matt’s playing it. It’s quite similar to the way Elliott Smith’s Lucky Three video was recorded although we used two takes panned hard to each side. A subtle corrective EQ and a light opto comp were all that I used on these acoustic tracks before riding volumes to match the band. Some of the other acoustic parts were recorded closer and EQ’d more aggressively.

“I recorded Lachie and Ed’s drum parts at my small studio space using Beyer M160s as overheads, an EV RE20 on kick and some Audix and Beyer mics around Lachie’s Gretch kit. I particularly love his 15-inch Zildjian hats and dry K ride. We thought drums wouldn’t work for Be Yourself as the guitars were played quite freely and we wanted to keep them. We persisted and eventually managed to get the drums to fit with the guitars and now it’s my favourite moment on the album. We didn’t want to wait until tracking was completed to see if sounds were working, so Matt gave me files along the way to start editing and mixing. The work ahead became obvious as well over 100 tracks appeared on my screen for a number of the 14 songs. I was blown away by the raw tracks, and confident that the risk of recording rough had paid off. A few tracks needed rerecording, and some ended up muted, but most tracks sounded great and the performances were fantastic. Some of the later tracks were recorded in other houses where the rooms had a harsh ambience that didn’t work on some instruments. We had to redo some parts and get creative with others. Despite the challenges Matt still captured some great tracks.

“I enjoy working with and mixing bands that record themselves, although it is high risk and comes with problems. It’s vital to find the right space and to have a band with great ears and patience. The process will typically take far longer to complete than it would in a traditional studio environment because of the trial and error involved, and it’s entirely possible for the expense to end up greater if things go wrong. It can also place a huge strain on people and bands. Thankfully Dear Universe was a great experience because Matt and Adam are naturally talented at tracking and kept at it, no matter how long it took them. It was also important that my tastes in sound were compatible with Matt’s.

POOR PLATE, EXPENSIVE SOUND

“The album was slowly mixed over the course of a year in my treated room on ADAM A7s. Most songs weren’t complete yet so we kept adding tracks and working on arrangements and sounds right until the end of the mix process. We were determined to be satisfied with the mixes so I spent a great deal of time buying and exploring new plug-ins and techniques until I got the result that I wanted, which was a great learning experience. Decapitator was great for shaping sounds and I typically used Waves SSL Softube channel strips for EQ. A few compressors used were Waves PIE and SSL bus, MOTU’s opto compressor, and the Elysia Alpha. I liked Echoboy and Crystallizer for lots of dirty ambience even on long string parts. I used countless bits and pieces for different flavours of effects and distortion and had a great time trying out some very unusual choices. One of the few reverbs used on the album was a free little plug-in called Poor Plate. It has a really unique rhythm and air that helps to avoid clutter. Matt told me he’d been running my early mix of ‘very impressive’ through poor plate because he really liked it swimming in reverb. It actually worked surprisingly well and after trying a number of altiverb, Softube, and Sonnox reverbs I had to admit poor plate was the best! I ended up using it on the final mix after bussing the beat boxing and bass to a separate output.

RESPONSES

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More for you